What Garage Door Material Is Right For You?

With a nationwide average return on investment of up to 98.3 percent, replacing your garage door is one of the best home improvement projects you can do this year! Picking a new garage door is an exciting experience, but, where do you begin? You may already know what cool features you want to be included in your garage door system, but that's only part of it. The aesthetic of a new garage door is important. There are many benefits to a new garage door, but stepping up your curb appeal is pretty fun in itself. Here are the three most common garage door materials and what you can expect from them if you select the material for your garage door:


Steel garage doors are great for the homeowner who values strength. Known for long-term durability, steel garage doors offer sturdy protection for years to come. If you live in a climate with harsh elements, steel is an excellent choice to protect your garage and home. Security doesn't get much better than with steel, either! For homeowners concerned about safety, imagine trying to break through a steel door. 

It's easy to see why steel garage doors are popular--longevity and simplicity. They also provide steady insulation, blocking out unwanted airflow. During a cold Buffalo winter morning, you'll be glad your garage is a comfortable temperature! Steel garage doors can look great, too. You don't have to sacrifice beauty for strength, with steel, you can have it all. 

Steel garage doors are:

  • Extremely durable 
  • Rust-proof
  • Affordable
  • Low-maintenance 


Wood garage doors are a gorgeous option and complement many homes, however, they are a much more high maintenance selection. For the homeowner who doesn't mind regular upkeep and maintenance, the aesthetic could definitely be worth it! Not everyone wants to spend their time staining and painting their garage door making wood garage doors for the patient homeowner. 

As a material, wood is susceptible to water and doesn't provide much insulation. It takes a lot of effort to make a wood garage door perform all year-long. That doesn't mean it isn't worth it to some--wood garage doors are generally customized to your preference and really step up the curb appeal of a home!

Wood garage doors are:

  • Classic, beautiful and authentic 
  • Dent-proof
  • Variety of prices
  • Custom-made


If you want to get close to the look of wood without the hassle, a fiberglass garage door is the right pick for you. With tons of styles, colors and wood-like finishes, it's easy to find the perfect match. Fiberglass doors are also affordable and lightweight, making them an easy option for the homeowner on the go. 

Fiberglass works well in a warm, coastal climate; the non-corrosive nature of fiberglass provides a door that is resistant to heat and moisture damage. You won't deal with any shrinking or warping with a fiberglass door! 

Fiberglass garage doors are:

  • Versatile 
  • Resistant to heat and moisture
  • Affordable
  • Variety of styles and finishes 

Western New York's Garage Door Experts

Remember to factor in the climate in which you live when considering a garage door material. For those in Western New York, a well-insulated steel garage door may be the best option to keep your garage comfortable throughout all four (very different) seasons. For questions about garage door styles and the ideal material for your garage door, contact Hamburg Overhead Door!